Editing Feedback

Could I have feedback for this editing please?

GI Brick Product Image Contest Part 6 Helmets Entry by First Rate Customs/HD Studios, on Flickr
Thanks!

The Glow around the helmets look false. Do a Drop shadow then add the glow, copy that layer and drop the transparency to about 10% place it as a shadow, about 3px to the right... Also use the clone stamp/repair brush to get rid of the dust on the windows. Then take a Black-ish color, drop it to %5 transparency and paint on where ever there is glare.

Hope this is helpful,
Octan

Octan wrote:The Glow around the helmets look false. Do a Drop shadow then add the glow, copy that layer and drop the transparency to about 10% place it as a shadow, about 3px to the right... Also use the clone stamp/repair brush to get rid of the dust on the windows. Then take a Black-ish color, drop it to %5 transparency and paint on where ever there is glare.

Hope this is helpful,
Octan

I might try that. And I want the dust to be there, it gives it more of a worn/outdoor look to it.

I like it

the green screen, try making smart outlines of everything except for the green and then change the background, instead of using the wand tool -.-